Fishing Lures Value & Price Guide

Collecting vintage fishing lures is a rewarding hobby that combines outdoor heritage with folk art appreciation. These intricate tools, ranging from hand-carved wood to early plastics, represent a century of angling innovation and craftsmanship.

History of Fishing Lures

The evolution of the fishing lure began in the late 19th century as makers transitioned from simple metal spoons to complex wooden plugs. Pioneers like James Heddon and William Shakespeare revolutionized the industry by patenting designs that mimicked the natural movement of prey, leading to the golden age of lure manufacturing between 1920 and 1950. During this period, companies experimented with materials like cedar and early 'Spook' plastics, creating iconic shapes like the Lucky 13 and the Swimming Mouse. These early designs were not only functional tools for catching bass and pike but also served as early examples of mass-produced American industrial design.

Value Factors for Fishing Lures

Rarity of the color pattern, with 'unlisted' or special order finishes fetching the highest premiums.
The presence of glass eyes versus painted eyes, which typically indicates an older and more desirable production era.
The overall structural integrity, specifically looking for 'age lines' or heat cracks in plastic models like the Heddon River Runt.

Tips for Buying Fishing Lures

Inspect the condition of the paint and varnish, as original finishes are significantly more valuable than repainted lures.
Look for lures with their original hardware, including glass eyes and specific hook styles like the 'L-rig' or 'toilet seat' hardware.
Check for the presence of the original box and paperwork, which can double or triple the market value of a common lure.

Items in This Collection

Have one in hand?

Snap it. Relic tells you what it is and what it's likely worth.

Scan yours with Relic →