Batman #251 Value Guide

- Period
- 1973
- Origin
- United States
- Materials
- Paper, ink
- Category
- Batman comic
Batman #251 is a definitive Bronze Age masterpiece that marked the return of the Joker to his dark, homicidal roots in the story 'The Joker's Five-Way Revenge.' This 1973 issue is highly collectible due to the legendary creative pairing of writer Denny O'Neil and artist Neal Adams, whose cover art remains one of the most famous in DC history.
What Is Batman #251 Worth?
The typical price range for Batman #251 is $1,500 - $1,500 based on recent sales. However, values can vary depending on the item's condition, rarity, and other factors such as:
- CGC or CBCS numerical grade, as high-grade copies significantly exceed the $1,500 baseline.
- Page quality and color vibrancy, specifically the deep reds and yellows on the iconic cover.
- Structural integrity, including the presence of both original staples and the absence of spine stress.
- Completeness, ensuring no coupons or 'Value Stamps' have been clipped from the interior pages.
How to Identify Batman #251?
- Verify the 20-cent cover price and the DC 'National' logo in the upper left corner.
- Check for the Neal Adams signature style on the cover art featuring a giant Joker card.
- Ensure the interior story is titled 'The Joker's Five-Way Revenge' with 1973 copyright data.
- Inspect the paper quality; original 1973 copies use newsprint interiors rather than glossy modern reprints.
History of Batman #251
Batman #251, published by DC Comics in 1973, is a highly sought-after Bronze Age comic book. It features the iconic story 'The Joker's Five-Way Revenge' written by Denny O'Neil with stunning artwork by Neal Adams. This issue is celebrated for revitalizing the Joker as a truly menacing and unpredictable villain, moving away from the more campy portrayals of earlier eras. It remains a cornerstone for collectors and fans of classic Batman lore.
Shop Similar

Batman (1940-2011) #251 by Denny O'Neil, Neal Adam…
barnesandnoble.com · $1

Batman #251 · Shortboxed
shortboxed.com · $350

Batman #251 · Shortboxed
shortboxed.com · $400

Batman #251 PGX 7.0 Neal Adams Classic Joker cover…
ebay.com · $780

BATMAN #251 VF- 7.5 CLASSIC JOKER STORY AND COVER …
ebay.com · $1500

1973 Batman 251 CGC 9.8 A-1 Restored. Classic Joke…
ebay.com · $12249
Related Items
Have an antique to identify?
Get an instant AI appraisal with values, history, and market insights.
Download for iPhone




