Brighton Square Earrings Value Guide

These vintage Brighton Square Earrings capture the 1990s aesthetic of Jerry and Terri Kohl's early jewelry expansions. Known for mimicking heirloom quality through intricate silver-plated scrollwork and resin insets, these pieces represent the brand's transition from leather goods to iconic American jewelry.

What affects the value of Brighton Square Earrings?

• Condition of the silver plating, specifically looking for signs of pitting or significant wear on the raised textured edges.
• Clarity and color consistency of the cream resin inset, as yellowing or scratches can decrease the $32-$35 market value.
• Presence of original Brighton packaging, such as the signature tin or decorative pouch.
• Functionality of the earring posts and the presence of original branded hardware.

How to Identify Brighton Square Earrings?

• Look for the signature Brighton 'B' heart logo stamped on the reverse side of the earring or the earring butterfly clutch.
• Verify the central cream-colored inset is a pyramidal shape with a smooth resin finish rather than natural stone.
• Check for the heavy, detailed textured border that mimics traditional handcrafted silver smithing techniques.
• Examine the silver-plated base metal for the brand's characteristic oxidation used to highlight the architectural scrollwork.

History of Brighton Square Earrings

Brighton Collectibles was founded in 1991 by Jerry and Terri Kohl, beginning as a line of men's belts. The brand quickly expanded into jewelry, influenced by the craftsmanship of traditional silver smithing. These earrings represent the brand's popular 1990s aesthetic, which often featured architectural shapes, intricate scrollwork, and various inlaid materials like resin or mother of pearl to mimic vintage heirloom styles.