Fiesta Covered Butter Dish Value Guide

The Fiesta Covered Butter Dish in Sunflower yellow is a quintessential piece of American Art Deco ceramic history produced by the Homer Laughlin China Company. As one of the original five colors launched in 1936, this vibrant yellow glaze represents the peak of mid-century kitchenware popularity and remains a cornerstone for serious Fiestaware collectors.

What Is Fiesta Covered Butter Dish Worth?

The typical price range for Fiesta Covered Butter Dish is $75 - $100 based on recent sales. However, values can vary depending on the item's condition, rarity, and other factors such as:

• Condition is paramount, as chips or 'flea bites' on the inner rim of the base significantly reduce the $75-$100 market value.
• The presence of the original lid is essential, as mismatched sets or base-only pieces sell for a fraction of the price.
• Glaze consistency and the absence of 'kiln marks' or manufacturing flaws on the visible surfaces of the Sunflower yellow finish.
• The clarity and depth of the impressed Homer Laughlin maker's mark on the underside of the ceramic tray.

How to Identify Fiesta Covered Butter Dish?

• Check for the distinctive concentric rings that are characteristic of the original 1936-1969 Art Deco design.
• Verify the Sunflower yellow glaze, which should be consistent and vibrant across both the lid and the base.
• Look for the 'GENUINE fiesta' or 'HLC USA' impressed backstamp on the bottom of the tray.
• Examine the handle shape on the cover; vintage models feature a specific proportions unique to the early production molds.

History of Fiesta Covered Butter Dish

Fiesta dinnerware, known for its vibrant colors and Art Deco design, was first introduced by the Homer Laughlin China Company in 1936. The Sunflower yellow color was one of the original five colors produced. Fiestaware became incredibly popular, especially with homemakers, and is now a highly sought-after collectible due to its distinctive style and array of colors.