Gurley Thanksgiving Candles Value Guide

Produced by the Gurley Candle Company in Buffalo, New York, these whimsical wax figures became a quintessential part of mid-century American holiday decor. This specific pair of twisted brown tapers is highly collectible for its detailed autumn leaf and acorn bases, representing the peak of 1940s-1960s seasonal design.

What affects the value of Gurley Thanksgiving Candles?

• Condition of the wax, specifically looking for the absence of melting, warping, or significant 'bloom' (white oxidation).
• Presence and legibility of the original paper price tag on the bottom of the candle base.
• Color vibrancy of the hand-painted autumn leaves and the deep brown of the twisted tapers.
• Completeness of the pair, as matching sets in original packaging or similar condition command higher prices than single candles.

How to Identify Gurley Thanksgiving Candles?

• Check the base for the original circular paper label featuring the Gurley Novelty Co. branding and price.
• Look for the characteristic 'sugared' or crystalline texture often found on the wax surface of authentic mid-century pieces.
• Verify the specific twisted taper design paired with molded autumn motifs like acorns and multi-colored leaves.
• Ensure the wick is unburnt, as unused 'new old stock' examples are the standard for authentic Gurley collectors.

History of Gurley Thanksgiving Candles

Gurley Novelty Candles, produced by the Gurley Candle Company in Buffalo, New York, became a staple of American holiday decor starting in the 1930s. Known for their whimsical and themed designs, these wax figures were particularly popular from the 1940s through the 1960s. Their Thanksgiving line, featuring turkeys, pilgrims, and autumn motifs like these leaf and acorn-based candles, brought festive cheer to many homes, becoming cherished collectibles today.