Shakespeare Criterion 1960 Fishing Reel Value Guide

The Shakespeare Criterion 1960 is a classic American baitcasting reel produced by the legendary Kalamazoo-based company founded by William Shakespeare, Jr. It is highly collectible for its representation of mid-20th-century angling innovation and its reputation for rugged, reliable performance.

What affects the value of Shakespeare Criterion 1960 Fishing Reel?

• Mechanical functionality, specifically the smoothness of the spool and level-wind gear.
• Cosmetic condition of the metal finish, including the presence of pitting, corrosion, or scratches.
• Completeness of the reel, including original plastic knobs and any original packaging or manuals.
• The presence of original factory lubrication or signs of significant aftermarket repairs.

How to Identify Shakespeare Criterion 1960 Fishing Reel?

• Look for the 'Criterion 1960' model name stamped clearly on the metal side plate.
• Verify the Shakespeare Fishing Tackle brand markings and the Kalamazoo, Michigan origin text.
• Check for the specific combination of metal housing and period-accurate plastic handle knobs.
• Confirm the level-wind mechanism is consistent with Shakespeare's patented mid-century designs.

History of Shakespeare Criterion 1960 Fishing Reel

Shakespeare Fishing Tackle was founded in Kalamazoo, Michigan in 1897 by William Shakespeare, Jr. The company quickly became known for its innovative fishing reels and other tackle, securing numerous patents over the decades. The Criterion 1960 model was part of their popular line of baitcasting reels, known for their durability and reliable performance among anglers of the mid-20th century. These reels represent a period of significant growth and innovation in American fishing equipment manufacturing.