Winchester Toothpick Knife Value Guide

The Winchester Toothpick Knife is a highly sought-after two-blade folding pocket knife produced during the brand's quality revival between 1987 and 1990. Manufactured by Blue Grass Cutlery, this model is a faithful reproduction of the iconic 1924 pattern, blending historical Winchester design with premium late-20th-century craftsmanship.

What Is Winchester Toothpick Knife Worth?

The typical price range for Winchester Toothpick Knife is $110 - $120 based on recent sales. However, values can vary depending on the item's condition, rarity, and other factors such as:

• Condition of the jigged bone handles, specifically looking for any chips or hairline cracks.
• Presence of the original factory edge and the amount of 'snap' remaining in the folding mechanism.
• Market demand for Blue Grass Cutlery era reproductions, which typically command $110-$120.
• The clarity and depth of the Winchester tang stamps and shield inlay.

How to Identify Winchester Toothpick Knife?

• Check for the long, slender clip point 'toothpick' blade paired with a smaller secondary blade.
• Verify the handle material is authentic jigged bone with nickel silver bolsters and brass liners.
• Look for the Winchester trademark stamp on the tang, indicative of the 1987-1990 production era.
• Confirm the high carbon steel blade construction which distinguishes these from modern stainless versions.

History of Winchester Toothpick Knife

Winchester Repeating Arms Company expanded into the cutlery business after WWI to utilize their manufacturing capacity. This specific model is a reproduction of their 1924 pattern, manufactured during the high-quality revival of the brand's cutlery line in the late 1980s by Blue Grass Cutlery.